Amberosia
10
12.5
–
Never
Collected Dust
Only for Slurtle, Snurtle, Rock Lobster
Asparagus Soup
20
18.75
Five
15
Asparagus, Vegetables
No Meat and Inedible
Asparagazpacho
Three
25
10
15
Asparagus, Ice or Ice Bream
Warly-specific food
Bacon and Eggs
20
75
Five
20
Meats, Eggs
No Vegetables
Barnacle Pita
20
37.5
Five
15
Barnacle, Vegetables
–
Beefalo Treats
73
25
–
10
Birchnut, Twigs, Forget-Me-Lots
Only for Beefalo
Banana Pop
20
12.5
33
Three
Cave Bananas, Ice, Twigs
No Meat and Fish
Banana Shake
Eight
25
33
15
Cave Bananas
No Meat, Fish, and Monster Foods
Barnacle Linguine
10
75
20
Six
Barnacle, Vegetables
–
Barnacle Nigiri
40
37.5
Five
10
Barnacle, Kelp Frond, Eggs
No Dried Kelp Fronds
Beefy Green
40
75
Five
Six
Leafy Meats, Vegetables
Not for Wurt and Beefalo
Bone Bouillon
32
150
Five
10
Bone Shards, Onions
Warly-specific food, No Inedible, Wigfrid can eat it while Wurt cannot
Breakfast Skillet
20
37.5
Five
20
Eggs, Vegetables
No Meat and Dairy
Bunny Stew
20
37.5
Five
Six
Meats, Ice
No Inedible, Max Meat value less than one
Butter Muffin
20
37.5
Five
15
Butterfly Wings or Moon Moth Wings, Vegetables
No Meat
California Roll
20
37.5
10
10
Sea Weed, Kelp Frond, Fishes
–
Ceviche
20
25
Five
10
Ice, Fishes
No Eggs and Inedible
Creamy Potato Purée
20
37.5
33
15
Potato, Garlic
No Meat and Inedible
Dragonpie
40
75
Five
15
Dragon Fruit
No Meat, Mandrakes and Asparagus
Fancy Spiralled Tubers
Three
37.5
15
10
Potato, Twigs
No Meats and Monster Foods, Max Inedible not more than two
Fig-Stuffed Trunk
60
56.25
Zero
10
Figs, Koalefant Trunks
–
Figatoni
30
56.25
15
Six
Figs, Vegetables
No Meat
Figgy Frogwich
Eight
18.75
15
15
Figs, Frog Leg
Use at least two Twigs
Figkabab
20
25
15
15
Figs, Meats, Twigs
–
Fish Cordon Bleu
20
37.5
10
Eight
Fishes, Frog Leg
Warly-specific food, No Inedible
Fishsticks
40
37.5
Five
10
Fishes, Twigs
No Inedible other than the required Twig
Fish Tacos
20
37.5
Five
Six
Corns, Fishes
–
Fist Full of Jam
Three
37.5
Five
15
Fruits
No Meat, Vegetables, or Twigs; Fruit value shouldn’t exceed two
Flower Salad
40
12.5
Five
Six
Cactus Flower, Vegetables
No Fruit, Meats, Eggs, Sweetener and Inedible
Fresh Fruit Crepes
60
150
15
10
Fruits, Butter, Honey
Warly-specific food
Froggle Bunwich
20
37.5
Five
15
Frog Legs, Vegetables
Use at least two Twigs
Frozen Banana Daiquiri
30
18.75
15
10
Cave Bananas, Ice
No Twigs and Meat
Fruit Medley
20
25
Five
Six
Fruits
No Meat and Vegetables; One Twig should be used as a filler
Glow Berry Mousse
Three
37.5
10
10
Lesser Glow Berry, Glow Berry, Fruit
Warly-specific food, No Meats or Inedible, and it requires either two Lesser Glow Berries or one Glow Berry, and a total Fruits value of two or higher
Grim Galette
One
25
Five
10
Nightmare Fuel, Onions, Potato
Warly-specific food; this recipe has no variations
Guacamole
20
37.5
Zero
10
Cactus Flesh or Ripe Stone Fruit, Moleworm
No Fruits; Use Twigs or Ice no more than two
Honey Ham
30
75
Five
15
Honey, Meats
No Inedible, Max Monster Foods is one
Honey Nuggets
20
37.5
Five
15
Honey, Meats
No Inedible; Max Meats should be more than one-and-half
Hot Dragon Chili Salad
Minus Three
25
10
10
Dragon Fruit, Pepper
Warly-specific food, No Eggs, Meats and Inedibles
Ice Cream
Zero
25
50
Three
Ice, Dairy, Sweetener
No Meats, Eggs, Vegetables and Inedible
Jelly Beans
122
Zero
Five
Never
Royal Jelly
No Inedible, and max Monster Food value is one
Jelly Salad
Zero
37.5
50
Six
Leafy Meats, Sweetener
Wigfrid can eat it while Wurt cannot
Kabobs
Three
37.5
Five
15
Meats, Twigs
No Inedible; Max Monster food value should be one
Leafy Meatloaf
Eight
37.5
Five
20
Leafy Meats
Wigfrid can eat it while Wurt cannot
Lobster Bisque
60
25
10
10
Lobster, Ice
Only a living Wobster can be used
Lobster Dinner
60
37.5
50
15
Lobster, Butter
No Ice and it’s safest to use Twigs as fillers since Meats or Fishes may create another dish
Mandrake Soup
100
150
Five
Six
Mandrake
No more than three Twigs or Ice as fillers to avoid making other dishes
Meatballs
Three
62.5
Five
10
Meats
No Inedible
Meaty Stew
12
150
Five
10
Meats
No Inedible, Tallbird Eggs, Mandrake and Sweetener; Max Monster Meat value shouldn’t exceed one.
Melonsicle
Three
12.5
20
Three
Watermelon, Ice, Twigs
No Meats, Eggs, Vegetables; Best to keep Twigs value to one.
Milkmade Hat
Zero
187.5
Zero
Zero
Naked Nostrils, Kelp Fronds, Dairy
No Collected Dust
Monster Lasagna
Minus 20
37.5
Minus 20
Six
Monster Foods
No Inedible. Damages Health and Sanity
Monster Tartare
Minus 20
62.5
Minus 20
10
Monster Meat
Warly-specific food, No Inedibles
Moqueca
60
112.5
33
Eight
Onion, Toma Root, Fishes
Warly-specific food, No Inedibles
Mushy Cake
Zero
25
10
15
Moon Shroom, Red Cap, Blue Cap, Green Cap
Don’t use cooked Caps as it may result in Ratatouille instead
Pierogi
40
37.5
Five
20
Eggs, Meats, Vegetables
No Inedible and Mandrake
Plain Omelette
Three
50
Five
20
Eggs
Max value of Vegetables should be limited to half
Powdercake
Minus Three
Zero
Zero
18750
Corns or Popperfish, Honey, Twigs
Fish and Mandrake will turn it into a different dish
Puffed Potato Soufflé
20
37.5
15
10
Potato, Eggs, Fillers
Warly-specific food; Don’t include Filler as Meat or Inedibles
Pumpkin Cookie
Zero
37.5
15
10
Pumpkin, Sweetener
–
Ratatouille
Three
25
Five
15
Vegetables
No Twigs, Dragon Fruit, Mandrake and Butterfly Wings
Salsa Fresca
Three
25
33
15
Toma Roots, Onions
No Meats, Inedible, Eggs
Seafood Gumbo
40
37.5
20
10
Eels, Fishes
Eel value should be less than two-and-half
Soothing Tea
Three
Zero
15 plus
Three
Forget-Me-Lots, Sweetener, Ice
No Meats, Monster Foods, Fishes, Vegetables, Inedible, Dairy, and Eggs
Spicy Chili
20
37.5
Zero
10
Vegetables, Meats
Don’t add Eels
Steamed Twigs
15
100
Zero
10
Twigs
No Meat, Eggs, Fishes, Monster Food, Nightmare Fuel or Dairy Ingredients; Only for a Beefalo
Stuffed Eggplant
Three
37.5
15
Six
Eggplant, Vegetables
–
Stuffed Fish Heads
20
75
Zero
Three
Barnacle, Fishes
Don’t add any vegetables
Stuffed Night Cap
Minus 20
18.75
Minus 15
15
Moon Shroom, Monster Meats
–
Stuffed Pepper Poppers
30
25
Minus Five
15
Peppers, Meats
No Inedible, Twigs, and Eggs; Max Meat value is less than one-and-half
Surf n’ Turf
60
37.5
33
10
Meats, Fishes
No Ice
Taffy
Minus Three
25
15
15
Sweetener
No Meat
Tall Scotch Eggs
60
150
5
15
Tallbird Egg, Vegetables
Filler value should be two, No Barnacles
Trail Mix
30
12.5
Five
15
Roasted Birchnut, Berries, Juicy Berries, Fruits
No Meat, Eggs, Vegetables, and Dairy
Turkey Dinner
20
75
Five
Six
Drumsticks, Meats, Vegetables or Fruits
Don’t cook the Drumsticks
Unagi
20
18.75
Five
10
Eel, Lichen or Kelp Frond
–
Vegetable Stinger
Three
25
33
15
Asparagus or Toma Root, Ice, Vegetables
No Meats, Eggs, Inedible, and Vegetables
Veggie Burger
30
37.5
33
Six
Leafy Meats, Onions, Vegetables
Wigfrid can eat it while Wurt cannot
Volt Goat Chaud-Froid
Three
37.5
10
10
Volt Goat Horn, Sweetener
Warly-specific food, No Meats
Waffles
60
37.5
Five
Six
Butter, Berries, Eggs
Butter is difficult to obtain
Wet Goop
Zero
Zero
Zero
Six
Twigs
This is failed dish